Wednesday, June 16, 2010

In Pastor Ed Kang’s Own Words – “The Letter” to Becky Kim

Aug 7, 2009 9:23 AM
In Pastor Ed Kang’s Own Words – “The Letter” to Becky Kim
by makestraight
I have found it sufficiently confounding that Pastor Ed and Kelly Kang refuse the acknowledge the sins they’ve committed, considering that both he and Kelly are guilty of similar infractions and sins that Ed laid out against Becky in splitting from Berkland Baptist Church.

Therefore, I thought it would be appropriate to use Pastor Ed’s own words in order to make my point against them. The following are various excerpts, not the full letter, from Ed’s letter to Becky.

I have removed any references to other names besides Ed, Kelly and Becky.


Try to read it with Kelly and Ed in mind, in light of this post about Kelly’s own deeds. [References to JDSN are references to Becky]:

Again, at the risk of being redundant, the main problem is your insistence on your nearly-inerrant role as a Pope-like figure. Since you can do no wrong, when you DO (and you do, indeed!), we must justify it. Often, you provide your own rationalizations, and we must accept them (and suffer inner damage), and pass them on to others, and crush any who don’t accept it. This is morally wrong. Anyone else who do what you do, say what you say, and have the kind of character flaws you have will be rejected as a spiritual leader. Yet, in the strange and warped BBC pastoral world, the reverse must happen. You become exempt from all normal criteria of evaluating persons; you become above the law. Up becomes down, right becomes left, wrong becomes right.

At no point during our Irvine meeting did you ever acknowledge any wrongdoing, or any truth in anything _____ and I said in Daegu. You continued to defend and justify, and occasionally, sarcastically admitted some small character flaw of yours here and there—“yes, I have a bad temper, but it’s because I deal with people’s sin.”

I am sorry to say, but JDSN, I felt that much of the conversation was inauthentic on your part. You were speaking words designed for impact—to melt my heart—without a strong commitment to truth.

And the fruit of your ministry often produced people who were emotionally dependent on your approval.

You are the inerrant pope, and we are just peons. We (the other pastors), for our part, play dumb and dull, but the whole thing smacks of the unreality and false ritual of ancient king-to-advisor relationships.

A loving person, according to your own teaching, is sensitive to the pain of others.

You queen-like behavior, expectations regarding how you should be served are also reflective of your narcissistic character. Why should someone else get rebuked for forgetting to bring your “han-yak” [this means oriental medicine, per hamcycle]?

Please acknowledge your responsibility for the trauma, wound, and damage to self worth you have caused in many. (And please understand why I cannot tell others, without compromising my conscience and damaging their judgment faculties, that your hot temper and abusive language is because you are like one of the OT prophets.)

Flattery, dishonesty, and fear. Many of the people you surround yourself with will not tell you the whole truth. You can do 9 things wrong, and no one will challenge you or offer criticism. But if you do one thing right, they will lavish you with praise. If they will not offer you criticism, they should not give you flattery either. You have become the emperor with no clothes. (But you have fostered this atmosphere yourself.)

For many BBC pastors, your approval means everything. But since it is often not clear what will displease you, given your moodiness, spontaneity, and unpredictability, playing it safe is at a premium.

Unhealthy view of marriage. As yet another example of up being down, and right being left in your world, happily married couples are made to feel apologetic for it. Their happy marriage is not, of course, a result of anything like emotional maturity, but a lack of commitment to truth, or a lack of spirituality by which the spouses are satisfied with each other. This is very unhealthy indeed, and has caused actual damage to many marriages throughout BBC.

Given all of the above, and more, I cannot, in good conscience, lead others who follow me into the strange and warped world in which you must be adored, followed, feared, and set up as a super-spiritual christian model, where common sense must be abandoned in order to believe all of your rationalizations, and your practices be imitated, and your moods and hot temper suffered. I think this breaks people. It is a wrong I cannot continue to perpetuate.

I refuse to continue to play part in the deceit, the fraud we are perpetuating upon the public, and upon our congregation. Personally, me and Kelly felt at times that we were going insane dealing with all of this over the years. No one else should ever be asked to go through this.

I think the passages speak loudly on their own, so I will not comment on it, and leave you readers to judge truthfully and common-sensically for yourselves.

I will say one thing. The only way to break the cycle of sin being passed down is through repentance.

52 comments:

  1. I am just disappointed. When I went to "About Me," you had nothing to say "About me."

    ReplyDelete
  2. A tad incongruent as Pastor Ed and Kelly SMN is just like Becky SMN.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Is the complete letter available somewhere?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have a copy but the person who shared it with me asked not to share it with anyone else.

      Delete
  4. Even Ed finally had his fill. So epic in so many ways.

    ReplyDelete
  5. how did u get this "letter"?

    ReplyDelete
  6. John, thank you for sharing this. Is there a way I can contact you in private? I'm a former Berklander (at Antioch Baptist Church for 7/8 years). I fail to find similar information and sharing like your blog about Antioch, and I'm surprised by it. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Leave your contact information here and I can try to contact you but I have had very bad luck with this. Not to be skeptical but there are lots of people trying to figure out who I am, I think. Ha!

      Delete
    2. Can I ask why you are trying to contact me? You know that Antioch Baptist Church is the first church plant from Berkland, right? Becky and Paul went to Boston to "plant" BBC East way back when and left Ed and Kelly to lead BBC West at Berkeley. Becky still had a HUGE influence over Berkland at Berkeley and all the other daughter churches until Ed and Kelly decided to officially split off, which this letter was a part of that process.

      Anyway, I'm not sure what you need/want to talk to me about?

      Delete
  7. I went to Berkland when I was a student at Berkeley. This church is a cult. They completely brainwash you. You are not saved unless you come to Christ within the church. Please stay away.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I don't see how this letter shows that Pastor Ed is at fault. What is it that you're even pointing out as wrongful about speaking out against a leader's abusive behavior? How else would you do it instead of communicating it to said leader - in this case, via letter? Please actually specify what you mean to point out. Pastor Ed was speaking out against what he believed to be wrong, and stood up for his convictions.

    You wrote, "The only way to break the cycle of sin being passed down is through repentance." which I was genuinely perplexed by because that's is PRECISELY what Pastor Ed wrote this letter to DO - "break the cycle of sin being passed down". He refused to let this continue in the house of God and took action instead of just obeying her. I am left completely confused as to what point you are even trying to make. Is it that Pastor Ed didn't say it cordially enough? This letter MEANT to strongly point out someone's harmful behavior. If Pastor Ed is correct about this person named Becky and decided to speak out against her unacceptable behavior, isn't he doing what you set up this blog to do - speak out against wrongful behavior?

    Also, I want to say - I think you should learn from Pastor Ed's example and speak to those you believe to be in the wrong DIRECTLY instead of talking behind their backs like this. If what you truly wanted was to actually rectify the problem, not rant in evident gleeful hatred instead of taking actions, you would respond to Pastor Ed's numerous attempts to contact you and speak to you directly. You're hiding, and those with honorable intents rarely hide.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "I refuse to continue to play part in the deceit, the fraud we are perpetuating upon the public, and upon our congregation." Missing are the details of his own contributions to this fraud, a knowing complicity spanning decades, which is heartbreaking because he is seen as a spiritual hero to many. His posturing in relation to the abusive charges in the letter are not only disingenuous, but spoken with the indignation of a practiced sociopath.

      Delete
  9. If you want me to not be anonymous, if you want to speak to me directly, here is my email address: parkys229@gmail.com. I hope in your good conscience you wouldn't block out my previous comment simply because it is against your opinion.

    And right now I am no longer part of Gracepoint church and I'm also not fully in agreement with some of its practices. But I sincerely believe Gracepoint is a God-driven church. For instance, when they brought up problems with an individual, they did it out of love and with the ultimate goal of wanting to help the individual. But your blog doesn't seem at all interested in that - you are set on viewing Pastor Ed and Kelly as some kind of corrupt figures and it's almost as if you would rather continue to view them as evil than forgive them.

    If you were undertaking this because you are convicted by God that wrongs must be put to right, you would directly bring up problems to them and work towards a solution, not spew out criticism after criticism. I see no spirit of love, no desire to even consider the possibility that Pastor Ed and Kelly would change if indeed they were in the wrong.

    While I was in Gracepoint, many times the leaders fully apologized for past talks or instructions and changed accordingly (even major changes in ministry direction) if, after more consideration, they believed what they did was not pleasing to God. For instance, even leaders were talked to by Pastor Ed and Kelly when the leaders quasi-segregated the students according to gender to discourage flirting culture in the church. Pastor Ed and Kelly corrected that and fixed it immediately. My own leader very humbly apologized for something she said because she thought she placed the blame incorrectly. Another leader was rebuked and removed from a leadership role for indicating that a student was chubby. If they came to see that an action or even a suggestion made may have been against what God actually wants, they always changed immediately. This showed me again and again that there is no self-interest involved - their hearts prioritize obeying God above all else.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Okay, after spending a lot of time with lots of Gracepoint people, and reading some posts here, I think the first observation and suggestion I have for Gracepoint folks is... stop using the term "leader" so much.

    You are setting yourself up for failure when you put so much weight and responsibility and expectation on a human.

    The way the terms are used, and their frequency, someone is either a "leader" or a "peer" or XYZ? is somewhat creepy and makes me shudder.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Uh... we used those terms all the time at Gracepoint? I was assigned a leader, so I referred to him as my leader. I had peers of my class, so I called them my peers. What politically correct name do you want us to call them now?

      Delete
    2. If it wasn't clear, I never went to Gracepoint. I have a lot of friends/acquaintances at some point were.

      1. Maybe just my limited data set. I often heard, "My leader said this and my leader said that," and it's pretty weird. It's okay to have leaders in a group, but the way they said it made it seem normal to them, but it's not very normal outside of that context. It's okay to say, "I learned this, I learned that," which at least implies more independent thinking. In comparison, North Koreans refer to their dictator as "Supreme Leader," and before that, "Dear Leader."

      Matthew 23:10
      Do not be called leaders; for One is your Leader, that is, Christ.

      Suggested alternatives: Servant, servant leader, teacher, under-shepherd, mentor, spiritual leader/mentor, class servant, etc

      2. Peers. While it is common to be grouped into your graduating class year, the frequency with which this term was used was also weird. Especially when those people are now several years out of college. The way I often heard it used also implied a lot of herd mentality and forced structure.

      Suggested alternatives: Brother, sister, friend, classmate

      Delete
  11. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Is it known for a fact that Becky was trained in the UBF system - are there any specific accounts to support that?

      Delete
    2. I did not hear first hand from Becky about UBF but having heard it from multiple sources, I do take it as fact that she was trained in UBF. I do see a lot of similarities between UBF and Berkland/Gracepoint, especially the goal to have ministries/churches near college campuses.

      Delete
  12. I have too many stories what has happened to me at Berkland, but nobody will ever believe me. I am thankful I am married to a very beautiful Korean Christian wife with two beautiful daughters. It is more than I deserved as a sinner even though I am scarred and branded for life as a Korean-American believer who basically did nothing wrong with the exception I presented the horrible truth what has happened to me at Berkland such that nobody will ever believe me since it seems so outrageous.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I am happy for the first time in my life after I left Berkland. My wife is the first woman whom I have kissed in my life. Yes, I did hear a voice which claimed to be from God that I will marry a Christian Korean beautiful wife, which came true, but it was not from God. The exorcism done at Berkland was outrageous. I should have sued the leadership what they did. You need to trust me that I am happy. I prefer to have real family who loves me instead of a fake church family where I am currently attending. However, my wife and my daughters made many friends in the local church while I am being alienated because of my forgivable past even though I have done nothing wrong with the exception I told the horrible truth that Berkland is a cult.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I feel for you and your family. Unfortunately it will be very hard to convince your brother when he is not open to any ideas that go against the church’s teachings. Keep praying and sharing your concerns. I’m not sure what more I can and then all the things that are written on this blog. Also I have not gone to gracepoint for a long time so I don’t know any current information.

      Delete
    2. I can certainly understand and empathize with this. I would ask your brother this -- in the manner that he treats your family, is it loving? Is it right to forego certain commands of the Bible in order to obey others? Is his life truly pleasing to the Lord?

      Delete
    3. I agree with the above and also encourage you to visit if possible. Emphasize that you are concerned out of love for your brother and not because you are against Gracepoint. You may just have to be very patient.

      I have known couples who left but from what I have seen, once you get married, it is very difficult to leave.

      Delete
  15. Hi, someone in my family is a student member of the same church, and despite heavy involvement, we realized too late what type of church it was. The signs of heavy indoctrination and personality change are unmistakable. They have developed a crafty way of slowly taking over a young person's life under the pretense of spiritual growth. The best resources I have found so far are Steven Hassan's writings on helping a loved ones liberate themselves. I will let you know if his approach has helped us. Perhaps this website could host a forum for concerned relatives working together to expose that organization for their deceptive and manipulative predation on people in a vulnerable stage of their adult life.

    ReplyDelete
  16. About 2 years ago today, I started having thoughts about leaving Gracepoint. I was a student who was attending their college group for 3 years. I also attended their high school group too. I came to a point where I was depressed in my relationship with God. I committed to ~17 hours per week serving, engaging in bible studies, and all the extracurricular activities they had me involved in. I was suppose to get quickly involved in student leadership before I transfer schools, but glad was able to think through these things before moving somewhere new.

    Being abnormally tired & spiritually dependent on my leaders made me realize how much I didn't have my own solitude with God. Yes, I did my private devotions. Yes, I prayed on my own. Yes, I read all the books they "encouraged" me to read. Yes, I talked with my leader(s) through my struggles. I had all the spiritual advice and methods BUT what I found was that I didn't have my own personal desire to do these things. I was completely dried out, so I started turning to other things. I hung out with brothers/sisters, started to rest more, and other spiritual care things, but got completely rebuked for not informing my leader about these things. I didn't know I was suppose to inform my leader all that I do? My leader told me his "heart was hardened" because of the fact that there wasn't a leader involved while I hung out with brothers and sisters. I was rebuked for many other things that I couldn't even think how it could relate to scripture. It just seemed like this leader was pissed off for not fitting their standard.

    A few months later (through research, time, and discernment), I left Gracepoint. One of my leaders found out and wanted to hang out with me to "catch up" and "see how I'm doing." Obviously and thanks to this blog, I knew what to expect because I talked with people in person who left Gracepoint years ago. I also had close communication with Pastors outside of Gracepoint on how I could handle this abuse and to ensure that it is one of the last times I have contact with them. They all knew things would not go smoothly in the conversation, and surely it did not. It was more like an interview. My leader asked me all kinds of questions about why I wanted to leave, what church will I attend, will I have accountability, will I be sharpened, encouraged, challenged, etc.

    I did not have confident "yes" answers to all of them, and due to that, my leader stated I would fall into "SPIRITUAL SUICIDE." At that moment, I knew in my heart I wanted to disagree, and so for the first time, I raised my voice toward this false teacher (James 3:1). I'll never forget that moment. It felt as though this was a first step into my own journey, my own path, my own story that God wanted for me. Because He designed me so unique. I told that leader, "you might be correct, but that's for me to find out on my own." From there, it just became a small but huge argument. I knew that this leader didn't really care about me. All the things I said just went out the other ear. This leader just thought I was going through a bad season and one day I'll get over it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Inspiring story! i wished as parents we caught the red flags much earlier to help our child see the truth

      Delete
  17. Now today, having transferred colleges and looking back at the everyday moments I had with Gracepoint, I believe I still have my relationship with God. There were dark moments I struggled without the same people I thought were my friends. But God was present. He provided me with a new community where I transferred to and has allowed me to heal so fast that I've been privileged to serve, intern, and lead at this community. He placed me in a setting where many other students experience hurt, brokenness, and sourness from Gracepoint. I've met many of these students//post grads who've left horribly scarred.

    It breaks my heart knowing that this "church" believes that they are a healthy church. On paper, they sound like one of the greatest churches to live out the Gospel. But seeing how things are played out, I cringe. I don't know that many who've left with positive experiences and wanted to return here.

    Now, as I continue serving college students while partnering with campus ministries, I better recognize the calling God has given me. To those who read this, open your eyes and realize how little your understanding is on how to run love someone and how to run a church. This goes for myself. But lean on His understanding (Proverbs 3:5). If you truly see the picture of who Jesus is through scripture, you'll realize He has never spoken to two people the same way. He speaks to us so uniquely because he knows us. No matter how much methodology, scripture, and advice a "leader" knows, it will never be enough to fully speak to your soul. Only God knows your soul. Only He allows growth, which is why I never grew in Gracepoint. I came to an end point in my walk with him while I was at Gracepoint. Maybe Gracepoint helped me reached to a point in my relationship with God that no other community could not have helped get to. But nonetheless, it opened my eyes to the ways a church should really be lived out in today's generation.

    Two quotes I want to leave you all with:

    “Given our disagreements over some points of the Bible, denominations are good, not bad, because they allow each church to follow Jesus according to conscience, and they keep strife between Christians of different convictions at bay. But if those denominations become the ultimate focus of our loyalty, then they are terrible idols. Keep clear fences but keep them low, and shake hands over them often.”
    ― Mark Dever, The Unadjusted Gospel

    "The gospel is not the news that we're okay. It's not the news that God is love. It's not the news that Jesus wants to be our friend. It's not the news that He has a wonderful plan or purpose for our life. The gospel is the good news that Jesus Christ died on the cross as a sacrificial substitute for sinners and rose again, making a way for us to be reconciled to God. It's the news that the Judge will become the Father, if only we repent and believe...
    Sometimes, it's tempting to present some of the very real benefits of the gospel as the gospel itself. And these benefits tend to be things that non-Christians naturally want, like joy, peace, happiness, fulfillment, self-esteem, or love. Yet presenting them as the gospel is presenting a partial truth. And, as J. I. Packer says, 'A half truth masquerading as the whole truth becomes a complete untruth.'
    Fundamentally, we don't need just joy or peace or purpose. We need God, Himself. Since we are condemned sinners, then, we need His forgiveness above all else. We need spiritual life. When we present the gospel less radically, we simply ask for false conversions and increasingly meaningless church membership lists, both of which make the evangelization of the world around us more difficult."
    ― Mark Dever, What is a Healthy Church

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Taylor, thank you for your comment and citations. Is your new community in or around Berkeley by chance?

      Delete
    2. Hi Taylor,

      I appreciate the quote but to reduce the Gospel to the death and resurrection of Jesus and his role as the substitutionary atonement for our sin is a very limited view of the Gospel. Coupled with our sinfulness is also our belovedness in God. Jesus died for us, and he also lived for us. There is as much to receive from the life of Jesus, as by his death and resurrection. I wholeheartedly agree that we shouldn’t love God for the benefits that loving God provides, but it’s not so easy to parse out when God is the source of all goodness and love. Remember what the Gospel meals, it is Good News. How often we turn this into Bad News for many.

      Delete
    3. Hi Taylor!
      What church or community are you apart of that helped you with your transition out of gracepoint? Do you have any churches or pastors that you could recommend that helped you get of gracepoint and seek healing? My older sister has been attending gracepoint for 7 years now, and we just now heard about all of this. We didn't know what kind of church gracepoint was until we got skeptical of the amount of time she was spending every day for the church and not doing much else.

      Thank you so much for your comment!! It was very helpful and I'm so happy that you were able to realize before it was too late!!

      Delete
  18. I have a question to the former members here, hoping it will help me free my family member, currently in her senior year at Berkeley, to escape the clutches of Gracepoint "church" before it's too late: suppose a student member starts to realize that Gracepoint isn't what it purports to be. Why would they still choose to remain in the organization, and continue on their path towards eventual arranged marriage and a lifetime of false commitment? Is it just a matter of having to start anew with all the friendships and the fear of facing life where she has to set her own goals and discover her own path?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is a whole host of reasons why one would choose to remain in the church, even when they start to have doubts. The social aspect is definitely an important one. If your entire social world resides within the church, as it is encouraged to be, one can see how scary it might be to be severed from that. I would encourage the person to start making some social connections and ties outside of the church. That may help her leave eventually.

      One may also stay by justifying the reason they are staying. Some things I told myself were:

      1. God wants me to stay
      2. Look at all the people being saved
      3. God is blessing this church
      4. No church is perfect
      5. So and so left and is miserable now
      6. I’ve already invested so much
      7. I am being selfish
      8. Etc.

      Delete
    2. John, thank you for your answer. I hope I will be able to get to a point with her where she may agree to read it. Why do you think the families of current members, as well as former members who have escaped after years of spiritual damage and manipulation, haven't organized to counter the church's recruiting on the ground? Seems like a big enough deal that enough people would be willing to donate their time and effort to prevent much of the suffering of future victims and their families.

      Delete
    3. The sense I get is that people who have left don’t want to spend more energy on anything related to or having anything to do with Gracepoint or don’t have the energy to do something like what you suggest above. That said, the existence of blogs such as this one and the numerous yelp reviews are some things that people have done to try to get the truth out there. I have talked/joked about having a conference or retreat for Ex Gracepoint members/Berkland members but that would be an enormous undertaking. There used to be a online community but that either got taken down or the person who maintained the site decided to stop.

      By the time a person leaves, they may want to leave all of it behind. A sentiment that I totally get it.

      Delete
    4. Clearly not - judging by your own blog and other people's comments, especially since you guys are just a tip of the iceberg - of spiritual pain and lost time and resources. And I mean that with the greatest sympathy and seething indignation on your behalf.

      Delete
    5. Dear anon, I understand. I guess a more thoughtful answer would have been: “We have organized… but not to the level that the commenter is asking about. Any guesses I have about why it hasn’t happened yet would just be speculation.”

      Delete
    6. Love you question, spot on "and continue on their path towards eventual arranged marriage and a lifetime of false commitment?" -- I recently watched a wedding of 2 GP members, and having attended many weddings in the past, I would say that it was one of 2 weddings in my entire life where the couple did not kiss. They were emotionless and unnatural, as if it was a quiet elegance and stoicism that were required of them. What is amazing is that it feels like couples who marry church members seem to be entranced by the promise of marriage longevity like an insurance bond backing up the relationship.

      Delete
  19. How is Gracepoint@UCDavis today? Will a student attending GP today face the same spiritual experience spoken of in this tread? Thank you, A Concerned Parent

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. From what I hear, things are still the same. I have not heard that any substantial changes have been made.

      Delete
    2. Former Gracepoint Davis staff here. Left pretty recently. It's still mostly the same people so I would advise to avoid.

      Delete
  20. Hi Anonymous! who just left Gracepoint Davis staff team -- would you be willing to share, what would "wake" a staff member to decide and leave?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes I would really like to talk to any staff member who recently left! I am a parent with an active member, now a staff. And she has spread herself so thin, being a generous (with her time and effort, and likely money too) and hard-working person, people-pleaser. Please continue the reply in the family member discussion? Appreciate so much!

      Delete
    2. @Anonymous September 29, 2021

      You should reach out on the reddit forum www.reddit.com/r/GracepointChurch. There's lots of former staff there, some that left within the last 1-2 years after being staff for 10 years+

      Delete

Please be respectful and nice.